BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
•	 Fair Identification Practices: Ensuring testing 
is conducted without discrimination, based on 
objective observation rather than bias.
•	 Defined Consequences:  Outlining clear 
disciplinary measures for refusal to comply with 
testing.
•	 Transit Planning: If you suspect someone is 
impaired and your reasonable suspicion testing 
is offsite, you absolutely must not let them drive 
to it. Have an employee drive them or arrange a 
driver to the test and then home. Letting someone 
drive, knowing you think they’re impaired, is a 
significant liability risk for organizations.
•	 Document, Document, Document: Establish 
a clear process for documentation around any 
activity that raises concerns and ensure it is 
applied uniformly across the organization.
Triggers for Testing
Triggers for reasonable suspicion testing are 
based on specific observations by supervisors. 
These include appearance, behavior, speech, 
and body odor changes that suggest impairment. 
It’s crucial to remember that these observations 
alone do not confirm substance abuse and could 
have other explanations.
Navigating State Regulations
With 15 jurisdictions in the U.S. having laws 
around reasonable suspicion drug testing, 
employers must stay informed about state-
specific regulations. These laws vary widely, 
with states like Alabama, Maine, and Montana 
imposing stringent requirements akin to 
federal standards for transportation workers, 
including the Department of Transportation 
(DOT) guidelines. Employers must ensure 
compliance not only with state mandates but 
also with DOT requirements for supervisor 
training in recognizing signs of substance abuse. 
Furthermore, several states offer incentives for 
maintaining a drug-free workplace, with rebates 
on workers’ compensation premiums available 
to those who comply with reasonable suspicion 
testing mandates.
Best Practices for Implementation
To effectively integrate reasonable suspicion 
drug testing into your workplace, consider the 
following best practices:
•	 Monitor Behavioral Changes: Stay vigilant 
for any changes in employees’ behavior, 
appearance, or hygiene as potential indicators 
of substance abuse.
•	 Document Observations: We said this before, 
but it’s worth repeating! Keep detailed records 
of any substance-related paraphernalia or 
behavior.
•	 Consider Medical Evaluations:  Before 
concluding substance abuse, evaluate if the 
observed impairment could be due to a medical 
condition.
•	 Educate Your Team: Ensure that your 
management team is well-trained in identifying 
signs warranting reasonable suspicion testing.
•	 Utilize a Checklist/Worksheet - Implementing 
a reasonable suspicion behavior checklist/
worksheet offers several benefits, including:
o Standardization: Using a checklist provides 
a standardized framework for supervisors to 
assess and document observed behaviors, 
ensuring consistency in the evaluation 
Experienced Counsel and 
Determined Professionals
• OSHA Defense
•
•  Construction Law
Workers’ Comp Defense
• Business Law
• Litigation
• Labor & Employment Law
Gary W. Auman  
Richard L. Carr, Jr. 
Donald B. Rineer 
Amy C. Mitchell 
Douglas S. Jenks 
Abigail K. White 
David M. Rickert 
Lindsey Deck
Jon L. Sutermeister
Lucas A. Strakowski
937-223-6003
amfdayton.com
Attorneys 
You Can 
Rely On for 
Effective 
Representation
www. mrca. org  —  Midwest Roofer
9

View this content as a flipbook by clicking here.